Monday, January 31, 2005

Ledgers and Sledges

There's a discussion at the Ledger forum about, well, the Ledgers and what can be fixed and what can be left alone.

And since i have very little going on, I'm going to prattle on about my suggestions for the next couple of days.

Categories


I'm probably not the only one who thought there were too many categories. With 19 categories it would either scare of people by its size or people faced with the idea of trying to think of who is the best letterer or inker just give up.

Even though I won it and I'm thankful i still don't understand how "Person of the Year" differs from "Achievement of the Year"; i think it would be better if it was amalgamated into the one category.

I think Design, cover artist, inker, colourist and letterer should be amalgamated into a single Art Design category. What you could do is on the nomination form (if nominations are suggestions made by the public) have a field where nominators state the field they are nominating a creator for; "Mark Selan - Design" and the final list of nominees shows this
"Karen Howard - Design
"L. Frank Weber - Cover Art
Doug Holgate - Inking
Annette Kwok - Colouring"
This gives a good guage of what people are recognising - if in a couple of years time, a number of inkers are nominated then they can get their own category. This'll stop people 'needing' to think of three names and then most likely nominating people on name recognition.

Whilst i like the idea of recognising Retailers for their work, especially the good ones, i feel that unless some other method is used to pick a winner, we may as well alternate yearly between Phase 2 and Kings. Though the two are great it doesn't help they both have large markets to vote for them.

I've been shrieking that Small Press and Independent Press needs guidelines. A book with nominations split over 2 categories may miss being included in the final tally due to confusion of its category.
For example
5 people nominate Knightsedge for Indy Press
5 people nominate Knightsedge for Small Press
Gary has 10 moninations in total albeit spread over 2 categories.
In the small press category though - the 3 highest books have votes of 9,8,7 so gary is out of the running for small press
in the indy press category - the 3 highest books are 8,7,6
Gary is out of the running in both categories even though he has more nominations. Sure everyone is in the same boat but those books that MAY be in both will suffer the most.

Otherwise I think the Ledger of Honour is great, we need to recognise the past and its creators. Same with New Talent category though it may be nice if there was some guidelines on what constitutes new talent would be helpful. But no biggie.

Finally, I'm not sure if comic strip is all that necessary since most webcomics are essentially comic strips anyway.


So
Achievement of the Year
Artist of the Year
Writer of the Year
New talent deserving recognition
Small Press title of the year
Independent Press title of the year
International Press title of the year
Anthology of the year
Strip of the year
Single Story of the year
Design of the Year
Retailer of the Year
Ledger of Honour

So down to 13 categories.

8 comments:

Tonia said...

I'd probably be even more ruthless with the pruning, but I'd definately put web-comics on the list as a separate category. It's a completely different format to say newspaper strips, and the nice thing is that everyone can go check them out when voting, unlike some of the other categories, in which people actually have to have seen the comic-in-question, to have an opinion on it.

Anonymous said...

Mark... I can't argue with your logic. I've copied and pasted your 13, plus added Tonia's 'Web' to make an even 14. A starting point for next year's awards.

Gaz

Mark Selan said...

Argue! Argue! go on, i'll fight! I'll fightchya!

Tonia - what other categories would you get rid off?

Anonymous said...

"small press" and "independant press" can arguably be the same thing.

Actually, come to think of it, they ARE the same thing.

though that's just me and my pedantic hole-punching.

cheers

-LFW

jon said...

horoscope matches info is so cheesy but we were looking at it anyway...why i dont know. I guess it is fun to play around online. Anyway, I saw your horoscope matches posts and though it was cool...Alright, well...have a great night, I am back to horoscope matches surfing LOL : )

Jon

Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here!

I have a custom dog coats site. It pretty much covers ##Custom Dog Coats## related stuff.

Tired of those knit sweaters, the ones that stretch out and have legs that your dog hates? Us too! So we came up with a coat that fits comfortably and works well! You and your dog will love these coats! We know, because we have been dog breeders for 23 years and know what dogs like.

All "Designer DoggieWear!" coats are handmade by ourselves in the United States. This assures the finest of quality and workmanship.



Come and check it out if you get time.

Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here!

I have a greyhound dog coats site. It pretty much covers ##Coats for Dogs## related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time.

Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here!

I have a dog skin and coat site. It pretty much covers ##Designer Dog Coat## related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time.